Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: [00:00:00] Welcome to Childfree Life by Design. Today, we’re talking about holiday, money, pressure and what it means for people who are building a Childfree life on their own terms. I’m Dr. Jay Zigmont here with Bri Conn, and in this episode, we’re covering the hidden holiday Childfree tax, how to spot guilt-based holiday spending before it wrecks your budget, actionable ways to set boundary backed gift expectations early in November before the holiday chaos hits. If you’ve ever wondered whether you’re obligated to buy presents for all your nieces and nephews, I say no, but we’ll keep talking about it, cousins and in-laws, just to keep the peace. This conversation will give you the clarity and the tools to make intentional decisions to support the life you want.
Intro: From Childfree Insights, this is Childfree Life by Design, the go-to resource for building the Childfree life you want. Every episode gives you practical guidance, clear direction, and meaningful conversations to help you live intentionally and design a future on your terms. This podcast is for educational and [00:01:00] entertainment purposes only. Please consult your advisor before implementing any ideas heard on this podcast.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: All right, Bri. So you and I were pre-prepping for this, and I asked you, “What’s the big holiday gift for this year?” And we both Googled it and asked AI, and we didn’t even have an answer.
Bri Conn, CFP®: Yeah. You know, starting this off, I am not a strong gift giver at all. So asking me to give gifts, don’t really know them. Don’t really know what the hot gift is. I just Googled what was the hot gift last year. Apparently, it was viral drinkware. That was something I wouldn’t have guessed. Cozy luxuries, interactive toys, things I never bought last year.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: But there are people that spend a lot of time. So I will tell you, for the people that I do give to, I spend a lot of time on it. So one of the challenges I have is my wife’s birthday’s beginning of December, and then you have Christmas at the end, so I get hit twice in one month. I’ll actually start end of summer trying to figure out one of the two gifts, and by Thanksgiving I have to figure out the [00:02:00] second one. So I do put a lot of time and effort into it. But let’s be real, I don’t do that for a lot of people.
Bri Conn, CFP®: And you shouldn’t have to because when it becomes that obligation to give a gift to everybody, is it really a gift at that point and really thought out and caring? Or is it just a, “I’m doing this because society says that I should”?
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Yeah, and I think I’m gonna kinda ignore the giving gifts to your spouse, ’cause that’s like a different argument than do you have to give it to every niece, nephew, cousin, something. I was just talking to a client who said they had a Excel sheet with everybody they had to give gifts to. I’m like, “Hold up. If you have to put it in an Excel sheet, you probably went too far.”
Bri Conn, CFP®: Just a little bit. I think at that point you could cut it down a few notches.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Let’s talk about this. So my sister and I, I don’t know, probably 10 years ago now, this is when Big Bang Theory was very popular, and they had a big discussion on gifts there. They’re like, “We just keep sending 50 bucks back [00:03:00] and forth until the last one dies, and that one gets the 50 bucks.” My sister and I looked at each other and went, “Yep, we’re gonna stop doing that.” What do you think about that?
Bri Conn, CFP®: I love it. I don’t think that you need to keep sending money back and forth like that because at one point you’re right, like, okay, great, we’re sending it back and forth for what purpose? Why? To me, it’s very different if you do something with somebody than if it’s just, “Hey, I’m getting you this thing or sending you money for this.”
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Yeah, and I think that’s part of the point. So one of the problems is as a Childfree person, they just expect that you are going to do this. Like you have extra money, so you gotta do it. And I just don’t think that’s real. I mean, I don’t know what’s coming out this year, but for a while there, I forget what it was, the Xbox or PlayStation was great examples of social media. People are buying those for themselves, and then their sister was like, “Hey, you gotta buy that for your nephew.” And I’m like, “No, I don’t. I can buy this just for myself.” And they’re like, “Well, but your nephew would like one too.” I’m like, “That’s nice, then he should go ask Santa, ’cause I’m not giving it to him.”
Bri Conn, CFP®: If you wanna know a fun [00:04:00] adjacent story to that is my aunt bought us the original Wii because she bought it for herself and loved it so much, so then she wanted one for us. Although my parents, if you’ve listened before and know how very anti-TV or video game or anything like that my parents are, and would not allow that, they were not thrilled that we got the original Wii. But I loved it as a child. In fact, I still have it, and you can find me playing Mario Kart every once in a while on it. So it has paid off.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: And I think there’s kind of just a societal thing. We get in this gift-giving structure, and let’s skip the holiday for a second, but one of my other favorite examples is, like, weddings. So the first one to get married has to keep track of everything their friends gave them, and then give an equal gift at least for the other friends. Now, my wife and I, we’ve kinda got to a point where most of our friends are already married, but there is kind of, like, an expectation that you at least gotta do the [00:05:00] same. And that gets that challenge of, like, are we really doing it for the right reason?
Bri Conn, CFP®: Yeah, I am definitely in the midst of that, being like, “Okay, what did they give us? We should at least give them what they gave us.” And I hate it. It’s so stressful to be like, “Oh, okay, yes.” And one of my best friends, she was the maid of honor. I didn’t really have a bridal party. But she was that person at my wedding, and she’s engaged now, and I’m so thrilled for her. It’s like, okay, do I need to match that? Like, what do I have to do? But I want to do this instead. Oh my goodness, the stress of gift-giving in our society is too much, and I am not a fan of it. But also, what does it say about us if we think that the amount of somebody’s gift to us depends on how much they love us. I don’t like that idea.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: I hate it all. I mean, so my wife and I got married in 2009, and the question is, “Where do you register for gifts?” And I’m like, “I don’t need anything from Bed Bath & Beyond, okay? Seriously. [00:06:00] I swear. So we, in 2009, registered at Target, and this is when Target had first started a program. They gave you a scanner, and you can go around the place, and you could just scan whatever you wanted. So, like, we wanted a TV, wanted something else I, like, put in, like, you know, Diet Coke and kitty litter. And a bunch of our family members got really mad at us because we registered at Target, and it had kitty litter on there. I’m like, “I’ll actually use that.”
Bri Conn, CFP®: It’s practical, really.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: But there’s just this, like, thing around gifts that you have to, like, put a lot of thought into it, which I 100% agree. If there’s somebody you believe you should gift to, it should be more thoughtful than kitty litter. But at the same point, we were trying to make a kind of a joke of it, and being like, “Look.” And I think really the best gift is cash.
Bri Conn, CFP®: Yeah. Cash or doing something or just [00:07:00] honestly picking some things up for your friends and making their lives a little bit easier too. That’s a great way to go about it. But I’m 100% a fan of cash, and I love that you registered for kitty litter. It’s so practical. It really is. Why are we not going for practical gifts anymore?
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Nobody got us the kitty litter, but I would’ve laughed my ass off carrying it back from the wedding.
Bri Conn, CFP®: I would’ve bought that for you had I known you at that time.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Okay, so let’s keep going on this for a second because one of the things we hear from clients is like, “I’m doing very well, but my friends aren’t, so I should do more for them.” And I’m like, “Ah, the guilt.” And there’s some cultural components of this, some religious components of it. There’s a whole bunch of things. But to me, giving gifts out of guilt defeats the gift.
Bri Conn, CFP®: I think so. Because it comes back to, again, are you doing it because you want to or because society says you have to? And I’m a huge believer in if you have, you know, more than enough, you should help. In fact, every single laptop that I own has a sticker that says, “If you are more fortunate than others, build a [00:08:00] longer table, not a taller fence.” But again, it shouldn’t be something where you feel like you must do it for a specific person because of X, Y, Z reason. There are people where you don’t have to do that for, and that’s okay.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: And let’s be real, if your friends are judging you based on the, I don’t know, size of the gift, or your family members, then they’re probably not a really good friend. I don’t know why I’m on a marriage kick, but one of those questions is like, “Oh, can you get an engagement ring?” And somebody said this to my wife, “Go get the ring appraised before you say yes.” And I was like, “Excuse me, what?” Like,
Bri Conn, CFP®: Was she supposed to be like, “Hold on, pause. One moment. Must visit the jeweler first”?
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: But that is– It’s hard coming to find out that’s real.
Bri Conn, CFP®: That is insane to me. No marriage for you.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: My wife’s gonna listen to this episode and get mad at me, but that’s the problem is when gifts are about money or like just showing that you have more than somebody else, you [00:09:00] lost it.
Bri Conn, CFP®: You really have. Along your lines of being super thoughtful of gifts, and it doesn’t matter about the money, when it comes to our family, we go on trips now. And for my birthday, I was like, “I really don’t want anything. How about we just do a trip instead?” So that’s what we did. And if I get something, what I’ll often do is I will print pictures of myself and whoever I’m giving the gift to, or just them. My sibling, I’m pretty sure half of their house is decorated in photos that I have gifted them of different points throughout life, and them with different people, because that is a lot more thoughtful than being like, “Oh, here’s something that I know you don’t actually want.” Whereas the pictures you have on display in your house and you like to show people them. So it doesn’t have to be a lot, and I’d rather then go do something with you and spend time with you, rather than collect more, hate to say it, but junk.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: And let me call it out. So one of the things I think people get wrong with gift [00:10:00] giving, same with kinda like celebrating birthdays, is they mix up the golden rule and the platinum rule. So the golden rule is to do unto others as you would have done unto you. That is like what I want, that’s what they should do. By the way, I am one of those, I don’t wanna hear anything about my birthday, okay? Like, seriously. My wife knows I will not go out to dinner if there’s any risk that somebody’s gonna sing to me, okay? That is like a rule. The platinum rule is to do unto others as they would have done onto them. What would they want? Which with gift giving it’s the same thing, but that’s really hard. If you’re gonna be really mindful about gifts, your example, the photos, all that, you love that, and I’m guessing a lot of the folks you give it to do, and there’s probably some that don’t.
Bri Conn, CFP®: I am very mindful of not giving photos to those people.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Right. I mean, my wife will randomly buy me stuff to put in my office, and I’m like, “You see all the crap behind me? That’s it. There’s nothing else going in here.” And she’s like, “Well, but this would look nice.” I’m like, “That’s nice. I don’t need any [00:11:00] more tchotchkes or crap in the room.” And it’s not because I don’t like it, it’s just I’ve got a system, I’ve got a structure. If I kept bringing stuff in here, it’d be full of stuff, and then next thing I know somebody would be commenting on something in my background and like, “Oh, you know, looks like a giant mess.” So I don’t want anything extra in my office. And then it’s like, my wife even say, “Well, you’re hard to buy gifts for.” I’m like, “‘Cause I don’t really care about gifts being bought for me.”
Mid-Roll: Don’t let the conversation stop here. Get inspiration, quick tips, and behind-the-scenes content tailored for the Childfree life by following us on social media. We’re most active on Facebook and LinkedIn. Just search for Childfree Insights. And for our deepest dives and event invites, make sure you join the inner circle by signing up for our weekly newsletter at childfreeinsights.com.
Bri Conn, CFP®: I’m sure you’ve done the love languages thing, but for me, I’ve done it, and gifts is real low on the list. Like, that is not my love language at all. I am time, [00:12:00] and my wife, it drives her nuts because she’s like, “Oh, what do you want? What do you want?” And I’m like, “I don’t want anything.” This year, though, she got me some tea from the Azores near Portugal, and I was like, that is the best gift ever because not only do I have tea and I love tea, but now we get to go to a tea store, and I get to find a fun tea steeper for loose leaf tea, ’cause I don’t have one of those. I don’t even know how much it was. Not much would be my guess. But that is a heck of a lot more thoughtful than going out and buying whatever hot blanket is today.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Well, you gotta be careful. So I started my wife on a bunch of those teas. She’s got a bunch of ’em. Like, I was in China, I got her some teas. Now we have card catalogs, the old-school card catalogs full of random teas and things. Like, once you get in that habit, it gets serious.
Bri Conn, CFP®: I already have one and it’s part electrolytes part tea, and then part spices.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: But that’s a meaningful thing, and it’s not really that expensive. Let’s be real. It’s just not. And that’s where you can find that [00:13:00] balance. So let’s talk about gift-giving to family members. So in my family, you know, as we’re thinking about the holidays, so I told you me and my sister, we said nope. She had her first child, and when I said to her, I said, “Look, I’m gonna start a 529 for my nephew. We’re gonna put a certain amount in there each month, and I’m gonna give you a receipt for that once a year, and that’s gonna be his gifts for the first three, four years. After that, I’ll give him something to play with ’cause he’ll know.” But, like, let’s be real, a one-year-old needs nothing. And she was very happy about it ’cause she knows, like, there’s some money set aside. It’s for a good purpose. I feel like I’m giving enough a gift. Now he’s, what is it, 14, 15, something like that. Now I’ll get him some video game or something or whatever to play with, but I still make the donation. And it’s just a way for me to feel comfortable. But really, like, the Christmas gifts I’m giving is, like, 50 bucks. It’s not much more than that. It’s just something for a token for him to open up. What do you think about that?
Bri Conn, CFP®: I like it that way. And we kinda do a similar thing in my family too of we’ve [00:14:00] got that trip we do, but then we’ve got a little thing to open. And this year I said, “Hey, I want some more running socks.” Like I already know you’re gonna ask me, ’cause I always get asked, “Can I get something that you can open?” Yes. Here’s some running socks. Here’s a link to them. I’d love those. If it’s important to the person to give you a gift and see you open it, sure. There are some people I am willing to indulge in that desire. Not everybody, but some I will. And that to me is a better idea. The 529, great way to set him up for the future and get him thinking about larger things versus, you’re right, like what are you gonna buy him that one that he’s gonna remember? Nothing. Maybe a baby blanket, but that’s probably few and far between.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Well, and if I go to a baby shower, my standard gift is diapers. I just buy boxes of diapers and drop it off. And now, mind you, now I found out some people are like, “I don’t like disposable.” I’m like, “Okay, seriously, we’re getting too picky now.” Like—
Bri Conn, CFP®: Okay, [00:15:00] so with the diaper thing, do you know what diaper kegs are?
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Yes.
Bri Conn, CFP®: That is a huge thing for a lot of people I grew up with is you have the baby shower, and that’s usually the women get together, but then the diaper keg is for everybody. And if you don’t, if you’re listening and you’re like, “What the heck is a diaper keg?” What it sounds like, you get a keg of beer, you’re doing a little bit of drinking, obviously not the expectant mother, everybody else, and then you also bring pack of diapers, and then usually a book too instead of cards. I love giving books instead of cards. That’s my favorite.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Well, my wife now, so she’s written two child kids books, one on ABCs of epidemiology, one on ABCs of public health. That goes to everybody now. Which is just a good science-y fun one, you know. Everybody loves it. But then we kinda cut into this, like, nieces and nephews. The question is, am I forced to do that 529 for them? Because that is actually almost an expectation for some Childfree people.
Bri Conn, CFP®: In my purview is no, you should not be forced to give to [00:16:00] anybody and anything that you do not want to give. Because once again, if you’re giving because of societal expectations, it’s really not a gift. And I would rather you take and say, “I’m really excited about giving here and really excited about doing this,” than give because you feel like you have to.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: And let’s look at some stats. So the National Retail Federation found that Americans plan to spend $890 per person on holiday gifts. That’s freaking ridiculous. Over 627 of that average goes directly to gifts for family and friends. And I’m like, man. And if you’re spending that on people you just, like, only talk to once a year out of obligation, I don’t get it.
Bri Conn, CFP®: I’m adding up right now how much that would cost me. If I included some of my family—
Bri Conn, CFP®: It would cost me over $33,000 if I was doing this. Absolutely not.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: And I think the one thing, by the way, that you will see me throw a fit [00:17:00] is when people are going into debt to buy gifts. I’m like, “Hold up.” And we’ve had to have that discussion in my family. So, you know, my parents will often used to always buy me and my wife and my sister gifts. They don’t have the extra money. They’re retired. They’re a fixed income. We finally said to them, “No, you’re not allowed to buy us gifts.” And my mother was very mad at us. And I’m like, “Look, you can fill the stocking with whatever you put in a stocking, you know, like whatever, 20 bucks, whatever, even Walmart. But no big gifts.” And she’s still kind of cranky about it, but it’s the right thing.
Bri Conn, CFP®: Having a limit on it can be really helpful saying like, “Hey, we’re not gonna do it.” I like the stocking thing, but if you have family like I have family, that stocking is probably gonna be filled with some cards for things that are a lot bigger that don’t actually fit.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Yeah, those are not gifts in a stocking. Like gift cards don’t count.
Bri Conn, CFP®: But they will try and make it that way, so you have to say, “No, dollar amount limit here.”
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: So you and I have worked together now like four years-ish.
Bri Conn, CFP®: Yep.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Do I gotta get you a Christmas gift? And do you have to get me one? [00:18:00]
Bri Conn, CFP®: No. But I—
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: And—
Bri Conn, CFP®: Excited for my holiday cards. It’s been a process, and you will be getting one of those.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Okay, a holiday card I completely get, and my wife will usually make something with our pets that we’ll send electronically. I have a friend that prints them out like six months in advance I’m like, “Okay, cool. You went too far,” ’cause I think there’s like, yeah, 2,000 people on her mailing list. I’m like, “Wait a minute, that’s not a friends and family list.” But yeah, cards are different. But there is this question of like, do you expect your colleagues, your boss to give gifts back and forth? And I’m like, “Getting ridiculous.”
Bri Conn, CFP®: Nah. No, I don’t think so. It is fun when I’ve had in-person jobs to like have a holiday party and then take in, you draw gifts or you play games for something. But beyond that, I don’t think so. And in fact, I think it can be really difficult in those situations to be asked to bring a gift. I was moved recently, and then we had a holiday party, and it was, “Oh, [00:19:00] everybody bring a gift. It’s gonna be white elephant.” Oh my God, I hated it. I was like, “This is my nightmare. I will show up and grin and bear it, but I really don’t like this at all.”
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: I hate all forced fun. Like the holiday parties, the white elephants. Like, I’ll do them, but oh, that’s painful. The white elephants, all that, Secret Santa, fine. If that’s what we have to do to get everybody to go along, that’s fine. But nine times out of 10 just causes issues. And I remember I worked for a hospital system, and every year first they gave us all turkeys, physical turkeys. And I was like, “Okay, fine.” Then they went to $25 Kroger gift cards, and I’m like, “Tell me you’re doing the absolute minimum you can,” and then you get the card signed by the executives, or the other one which is really popular is they will have lunch in the cafeteria and the executives serve you food, so that’s a big thing. And I’m like, “Okay, fine.” But this gift-giving just goes too far.
Bri Conn, CFP®: It really does, and I think at a certain point you need to [00:20:00] decide not only if you’re gonna do it for anybody, but let’s say, hey, you wanna do it and sure, you wanna give gifts, that can be a great kids only rule of, “Okay, we’re gonna give gifts, but we’re only giving to the kids.” The one side of the family for me growing up was, we’re gonna give gifts, but the gifts are only gonna be given to our godchildren. So it was kids only, and it’s only your godchild. So that meant everybody had one, maybe two people to give a gift to, versus feeling like they needed to give it to everybody. And hey, you get at 18, probably not gonna get a gift anymore. Don’t expect one after that. I think that’s perfectly fine, but having those conversations can be tricky, and also even starting the conversation. I don’t really feel bad about saying, “Hey, I’m not participating in this,” or, “I will participate in this. Please say what one would like,” anything like that, versus guessing.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: This is coming out in November. We’re like, okay, now’s the time to do that preemptive strike and say, “This [00:21:00] is our plan.” The most awkward thing, in particular for guys, is when you get a gift from a friend and you haven’t gotten them something. Guys normally don’t give gifts to other guys. Like, it’s just not as popular.
Bri Conn, CFP®: True.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Come on.
Bri Conn, CFP®: I’m a lesbian, so I don’t know. I’ve asked Wendy to check on this, but I’ll take your word for it.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: It’s rare. Not a normal thing. And then once you do, you’re like, “Shit, I didn’t get him anything. Like, do I have anything? Oh, I guess on my desk here you can have,”
Bri Conn, CFP®: Fair. Yes. I don’t really have a lot of male friends. I mean, I have some, but yeah, I could see that being a thing. I don’t think it’s just a guy thing, though. I think women can do that, too. We’re definitely not gift-givers. We have one friend, we hosted a party for Super Bowl, and she’s like, “Oh, I got you a gift.” I’m like, “Oh, thanks. I didn’t get anything when I went over to a party at your house. Like, am I supposed to? I didn’t.” So that awkwardness, I think, crosses gender lines. It’s not just one or the other. But yeah, very [00:22:00] awkward if we’re talking about it. I think we have hit on a lot of points, and in summary of today’s episode, no is a complete sentence. You do not need to buy gifts for everybody. But if you would like to give gifts, you should do it intentionally in ways that allow you to have joy in the gift-giving, but also allows for the recipient to enjoy as well. And be starting those conversations now, so that way you don’t hit the holidays this year and find yourself in an awkward conversation.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: Yep. And as you start looking at this, have a plan is the key. I mean, you could always buy them a copy of The Childfree Guide to Life and Money. I’m good with that. Gotta put the shameless… I mean, you know, if we’re gonna give gifts, we might as…
Bri Conn, CFP®: Perfect one.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: You’d be surprised how many people I give random books to. Those aren’t gifts in my mind. Those are like, “Hey, I’ve read this. I thought of you.” I guess somebody would call that a gift, but I’m like, I don’t know. It’s the gift of [00:23:00] knowledge, and it’s like 12 bucks.
Dr. Jay Zigmont, CFP®: All right, so that’s all for this episode of Childfree Life By Design. Remember, intentionally choosing to invest in moments of joy is just as important as investing in your future. Until next time, happy designing.
Outro: You’ve been listening to Childfree Life by Design. Make sure you follow the show, leave a rating or review, and connect with us on social @childfreeinsights. For more resources, guides, or upcoming events, visit childfreeinsights.com.